John C. Kirk (johnckirk) wrote,
John C. Kirk

Harry Potter

Well, I've just finished reading "Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix", which took me about 10 hours altogether. No spoilers here, but it's a very good book. It seems like the events of the previous four novels have all been building towards this, ready to kick into high gear, which is impressive since they were good stories in their own right. There's an all-star cast, with some familiar faces that I didn't expect to see showing up. We also see characters in a new light, and there are some surprising allegiances formed. I was particularly impressed by the events concerning Neville and Snape (who I think is the most complex character in the series).

It is clear in this book that Harry is definitely getting older. The main issue here is that we get to see more of the adults in the story; in particular, they interact with each other independently of Harry. I've been thinking recently about "the innocence of youth", and I think that it's not so much innocence vs guilt as it is a matter of awareness - young children tend to be fairly self-centred. It's similar to Tolkien's stories - when I read "The Hobbit", I sympathised with Bilbo, since Gandalf had sent him off in his quest, then basically abandoned him. When I then read "Lord of the Rings", it turned out that Gandalf did have other responsibilities to attend to, i.e. a life of his own that didn't revolve around Bilbo. There are similar themes that appear here.

To use a phrase from "Babylon 5", this is the year that everything changed. It was certainly interesting to read all the new developments. Following the trend of the previous books, the subject matter is getting darker, and some parts of it were genuinely unpleasant. However, there are funny bits spread around the book, to keep it from being too depressing.

One thing that did strike me about this book is that it's clearly aimed at people who have read the other four, or at least seen the films, which I think is a safe assumption. While there are a couple of brief recaps to jog your memory, there's no standard introduction. So, for instance, the book refers to Muggles without explaining what the term means.

Another impressive achievement is that I read about (yet another) Quidditch game, but it still kept my attention. I think it's quite a challenge to write about so many games, and yet keep them distinct.

So, all in all, a great book - well worth the money. And given the amount of publicity surrounding the launch, I'd recommend reading it sooner rather than later, to maximise your chances of avoiding spoilers. Oh, and incidentally, I definitely like the fact that the hardbacks are approximately the same height as the paperbacks, rather than being oversized - this makes it much easier to shelve them.
Tags: books, harry potter

  • Free stuff

    I'm having another clear-out, to get rid of some of my accumulated clutter. If anyone would like any of these items (free of charge), just let me…

  • Computer exams

    I think this xkcd strip is quite true: Some people have questioned whether Randall Munroe can really claim that with authority, since he's too…

  • Full moon swims

    As I've mentioned before, I like outdoor swimming when the sun's out: the water looks very inviting when I can see the sunlight reflecting off it.…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded